The Daily Tea
The Agunah Chronicles
The Agunah Chronicles
February 24, 2026

Episode 4

The Smear Campaign

By: Faigie Carmel

Listen to this article~5 min

My parents started reaching out. Who knew my (still) husband? Who would he listen to? (Anyone???) As people found out what was happening, we started getting responses.
Living in a fishbowl was excruciating.

People felt entitled to advise, comment, patronize, and judge me. There’s a Yiddish truism: “Why do people get divorced? Because he’s a sheigetz, or she’s crazy… or both.”

That seemed to be the consensus of random people who knew nothing about me or my relationship. A lot of my boundaries were crossed under the guise of “helping.” People wanted to help fix everything—all without familiarizing themselves with the details of the situation—and then I had to sweep up the mess they made in my space.

Lesson of the day: “Don’t interfere before you interpret!” (A quote from Rabbi Shimon Russel).

Some people began to share horror stories with my parents about Agunot who waited interminably for a Get. Mostly, the stories had no practical applications. It was very demoralizing.

One good soul spent hours being righteously indignant on my behalf.

“You’re so young. You shouldn’t have to wait so long for a Get!”... but then they often seemed to veer off into the helpless territory of, “But what can you do?”

Those conversations were exhausting. I kept wondering why I was developing a quiet resentment for people who “just really cared about me.”

Finally, I snapped, “Why don’t you say all this to HIM?”

So they did. They told my (still) husband, “You’re so young and have so much going for you. Why should you wait so long for a Get? You should be free to pursue another connection. ‘It is not good for man to be alone.’”

“I listen to my parents,” my (still) husband declared, “and Halachically, I don’t have to give her the Get for my needs to be met. Only SHE is prohibited… but I don’t think it will make a difference to her. It hasn’t mattered to her until now, anyway.”

“What are you saying?”

“I think you know what I am saying. You would be shocked to hear what I have really been through with her. That’s not even including all the mental health issues.”

People with character disturbances are very fragile. They worry about looking good. They need the way other people see them to match the way they like to be seen; otherwise, they may have to face what they actually look like. The reality of being a flawed human is too excruciating for them to bear.

I experienced a year and a half of living with someone who always found external circumstances to blame for every hiccup in our relationship. It was either the fault of life, random other things, or my fault—but never, ever his fault. If I was unhappy, or if things felt strained, there always had to be a reason—but never, ever his actions, his relationship skills, or the marital dynamic he was creating.

He never took responsibility for anything less than perfect. I never received an apology because he arranged to never have anything to apologize for. If he had to admit there was a crack in his armor, his entire personhood would shatter. Maybe he’d die.

He wasn’t going to find out.

When your image is all you have, you’re always focused on PR. Looking good is critical. (Being good is optional.)

Divorce is NOT a good look—unless you’re the victim, then you can still get pity points. Divorce is intolerable to people with character disturbances. It brings up big fears for them: a loss of power, a loss of admiration from society, and a loss of the ability to shape all narratives regarding themselves. Someone out there, not in their control, exists as a living testament that they weren’t always perfect.

The response? Rewriting history to cast themselves as a victim, trying to destroy your credibility so nobody believes your side, seeking attention and sympathy from others to reinforce their own narrative, and triggering you in terrible but nearly undetectable ways to make you look unstable so that they can feel justified and superior.

It’s not about the truth or facts. It’s about image management and regaining control. Next time you meet a Get-refuser, keep this in mind: Your favorable opinion is life-and-death for them, and way more critical to them than the truth.

To be continued...

Sign up to save this article

Create a free account to bookmark your favorite articles and access them anytime.

Already a member?

F

About the Author

Faigie Carmel

Faigie Carmel volunteers for GET Jewish Divorce Justice, the only Agunah advocacy organization on the West Coast, founded by Esther Macner, Esq. For the past three years, she has written up the accounts of Agunot for 'The Agunah Monologues', a project that began as a way to give voice to survivors of Get Abuse and Extortion. Some of the accounts are published on the website. If you or anyone you know is struggling to receive a Get, call Esther Macner at 310-730-5282 or email her at info@getjewishdivorce.org. Strictly confidential.

You Might Also Like

Was My Aunt Right?
marriage

Was My Aunt Right?

Jul 5, 2026
IS BAIS DIN A DEAD END?
marriage

IS BAIS DIN A DEAD END?

May 28, 2026
Being a Torah Wife, Without Being a Kollel Wife
marriage

Being a Torah Wife, Without Being a Kollel Wife

May 19, 2026

Don't miss next week

Sign up to get every new episode of our serials.

Stay in the Loop

Get the latest articles, recipes, and community highlights delivered to your inbox.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.